Sun-faded Summer Sale: 20% off $150+ | Use code: SUNFADED

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $150

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS HAD TO SAY

RUGBY REVIEWS

Based on 315 reviews
93%
(294)
4%
(14)
1%
(4)
1%
(2)
0%
(1)
A
Pelagic Rugby Shirt
A.M. (Brooklyn, US)
The perfect thing

Wow I love this thing. Soft, dense, hardwearing but not too heavy for spring. Drop shoulders are a nice touch. Cuffs are tight, but better they start out tight and stretch than flop around from the start (and the arms are well long enough on a size M, which helps). Absolutely worth the price. Can't wait to see what else they produce.

A
Fitz Roy Rugby Shirt
Andrew (Amherst, US)
Great quality shirt

I was a bit hesitant to spend so much on "just a rugby shirt" -- generally I buy everything on sale! But I wanted to give it a try, and I have to say I'm not disappointed. Quality is very good compared to today's fast fashion with brighter colors and thicker/nicer material. I only spent $15 for my Old Navy rugbies as I got them on clearance so of course you expect this to be better, but even compared to the $75 Vineyard Vines rugby I tried out, the quality and fit of this shirt is much, much better. I'll have to pick up a couple more!

For fit, I'm 6'2" 190 with long arms and I found the large to fit good though still a bit long in both the torso and sleeves, but I think that's the traditional rugby fit. After a run through the washer/dryer it fit me just about perfect.

Great quality.

Good, Heavy Duty Cotton.

s
Whistler Rugby Shirt
scott t. (Huntingtown, US)

Shirt was a present for my son.
I have had rugby shirts as a kid & wanted to pass along the tradition! However, the Ulysses was the one he really wanted - not available.
Well, maybe there's a next time?
Great shirt & will last a lifetime.
All the best & take care.
regards,
scott

S
Aspen Rugby Shirt
SJ (Portland, US)
#bestrugbyshirtsever

Perfection in a rugby shirt

C
Voyageur Rugby Shirt
C. (Weedsport, US)
CANADIAN SUNSET

You should play the big 1956 hit "Canadian Sunset" as background music for your Voyageur promotion.

C
Voyageur Rugby Shirt
C. (Glen Ellyn, US)
Fine Shirts

Fantastic shirts - I purchased the Stonemaster and the Sierra. The shirts are well made, constructed of durable fabric, with bright and vibrant colors. Now, regarding sizing: based on another review, which stated that one should size up, do not, absolutely do not, size up when purchasing any of Withernot's shirts. These are the most generously sized shirts I've ever encountered (I wear Brooks Brothers shirts, so, I'm used to a generously cut shirt, but these shirts go beyond.). It is rather nice to encounter a company that doesn't cut corners when manufacturing with regards to sizing. I wear an XL and sized up to an XXL based on the review I read and allowing for shrinkage. The shirts were comically large. Huge. I worked with Patrick at Withernot and exchanged the shirts for an XL. The XL was also too large. Back they went. Patrick exchanged the shirts for a large, and the fit on both shirts is excellent. Overall length of the shirt is good, sleeve length is good, and there is room to move in the shoulders and the torso.
The return process was effortless, and made so by Patrick's fast, efficient, and friendly customer service. Excellent shirts and a fine company to work with.

J
Aspen Rugby Shirt
JF (Anaheim, US)
Strong shirt, weak buttons

Love the shirt. Fit, fabric, coloring all excellent. But the buttons are weak. The buttons are a soft rubber. But the stitching on the button actually snapped the button in half. I had to sew on my own replacement button which was easy enough.

S
Pelagic Rugby Shirt
SJ (Portland, US)
Top quality

Every inch demonstrates exceptional quality in materials and construction. Very impressed. Love the shirt

C
Voyageur Rugby Shirt
C. (Grand Forks, US)
Great shirt!

I've had this shirt for about 6 months now. Wear it approximately once a week, and it is holding up great! The fit (as expected) is a bit full & boxy, but very comfortable & the fabric is nice & heavy. Looking forward to many more years of use!

B
Katahdin Rugby Shirt
Burdett P. (Sayre, US)
Outstanding Quality

Withernot uses a very thick material to construct these shirts. They demonstrate durability. Very impressive.

J
Stonemaster Rugby Shirt
J.R. (Ardmore, US)
Perfection across the board

Well done! The ultimate year-round / no-worries shirt. Dresses up or down, goes with everything from shorts to khakis to jeans to blazers. Classic colors and built really tough but has a subtly refined fit without losing its brawn. (Bonus: it's slimming.) Gotten a lot of compliments.

A
Stonemaster Rugby Shirt
Angus M.T.J. (Jackson, US)
Good shirt

I like it. Finally...

Feels like I’ve gone back in time to when they made clothes built to last! Feels great and looks good, too.

D
Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Damon R. (Seattle, US)
Quality is apparent

Even before taking out of the package, the weight alone told me this shirt was different. The material is heavy duty, yet soft enough to feel comfortable on the skin. Quality weave and stitching with nice, understated buttons. I like that the brand logo is discreet. Colors are bold. This is easily twice the shirt compared to more high profile brand names. Runs slightly larger than other brands. I am happy with the purchase and will buy again if it ever wears out.

B
Stonemaster Rugby Shirt
B. G. (Silver Spring, US)
Awesome

A heavyweight rugby that will last forever. Does run big and long in hem and sleeves. 5’9, 185 with broader shoulders, had to return a large for a medium. Customer service was great and replacement arrived super fast. Highly recommend.

P
Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Paul L. (Atlanta, US)
Love these rugby shirts!

Withernot delivers a fantastic rugby shirt with a higher quality and attention to detail you can't find anywhere else. Rugged yet stylish, this shirt is durable and versatile—the perfect companion for outdoor adventure or a night on the town.

C
Aspen Rugby Shirt
Charles L.
Great!

Wearing it currently on a cruise to the Antarctic Peninsula. Very rugged.

J
Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Jorge C. (San Diego, US)
Wow!

This is possibly my favorite shirt of all time!
The quality is just phenomenal, it fits amazingly, and it makes me look so friggin' good!😎

I already told my GF what I want for the rest of my birthdays!

J
Stonemaster Rugby Shirt
Joe C. (Tucson, US)
Just like the ole days

I wore out a few rugby shirts back in the 70’s and 80’s working on trails and hiking in Wilderness Areas in Idaho. My new Stonemaster is the first since then built to handle some serious wear and tear. I’m looking forward to putting this one to the test!

J
Blue Ridge Rugby Shirt
Jason S. (Kittery Point, US)
Shirts Are Awesome

This is my second Withernot rugby shirt and they’re awesome. Was looking for a vintage rugby like the Land’s End rugby shirts I wore back in the late 80’s and these are as good if not better. Excellent quality and super comfortable. Great colors too. Highly recommend, you wont be disappointed. Im sure I’ll buy another at some point.

G
Pelagic Rugby Shirt
Gregg D. (Austin, US)
Quality, classic

My new rugby shirt is as classic as it comes. Very nice, heavyweight material. Definitely recommend!

C
Pelagic Rugby Shirt
Cole L. (Tempe, US)
Great quality, great color

The color is awesome. I’m 6’3”, 225 with broad shoulders and I got the XXL. It was too big at first but then I ran it in the dryer for like thirty minutes and it shrunk to the perfect fit. This rugby has a great hand feel and drape. I plan on getting at least one more color way.

#1 Rugby Shirts

This is my 7th Withernot and I don’t plan on stopping. The quality is impeccable, service is superb, and colors always rock. Can’t wait for the next go ‘round of designs!