Based on 290 reviews
Aspen Rugby Shirt
Charles L.

Wearing it currently on a cruise to the Antarctic Peninsula. Very rugged.

Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Jorge C. (San Diego, US)

This is possibly my favorite shirt of all time!
The quality is just phenomenal, it fits amazingly, and it makes me look so friggin' good!😎

I already told my GF what I want for the rest of my birthdays!

Stonemaster Rugby Shirt
Joe C. (Tucson, US)
Just like the ole days

I wore out a few rugby shirts back in the 70’s and 80’s working on trails and hiking in Wilderness Areas in Idaho. My new Stonemaster is the first since then built to handle some serious wear and tear. I’m looking forward to putting this one to the test!

Blue Ridge Rugby Shirt
Jason S. (Kittery Point, US)
Shirts Are Awesome

This is my second Withernot rugby shirt and they’re awesome. Was looking for a vintage rugby like the Land’s End rugby shirts I wore back in the late 80’s and these are as good if not better. Excellent quality and super comfortable. Great colors too. Highly recommend, you wont be disappointed. Im sure I’ll buy another at some point.

Pelagic Rugby Shirt
Gregg D. (Austin, US)
Quality, classic

My new rugby shirt is as classic as it comes. Very nice, heavyweight material. Definitely recommend!

Pelagic Rugby Shirt
Cole L. (Tempe, US)
Great quality, great color

The color is awesome. I’m 6’3”, 225 with broad shoulders and I got the XXL. It was too big at first but then I ran it in the dryer for like thirty minutes and it shrunk to the perfect fit. This rugby has a great hand feel and drape. I plan on getting at least one more color way.

#1 Rugby Shirts

This is my 7th Withernot and I don’t plan on stopping. The quality is impeccable, service is superb, and colors always rock. Can’t wait for the next go ‘round of designs!

Dockside Rugby Shirt
Robert Y. (Tavernier, US)
Excellent shirt

I initially purchased a size large but it was too big (I’m 6 foot 1 inch and 180lbs) which I returned and the medium fits perfectly. I’ve washed it once and it shrunk a bit even with air dry, but the shirt has some flex to it so it still fits perfectly. I’m definitely buying another color soon.

Aspen Rugby Shirt
Richard L. (Walla Walla, US)
Fabulous rugby shirt

I love these shirts! Hand down, the best I’ve found. Sturdy and rather heavy, they are perfect for north Idaho winters.

Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Anonymous (Sanford, US)
Ulysses Shirt

Great looking shirt with soft, heavy fabric. I followed the sizing chart and ordered a Large but it was too large and not very flattering on me. Returned it for a Medium which fits great. For others, I’m 6’4” 220 with 44L coat and the medium fit best. Got compliments while wearing it in public. Nice for 50-65 degree weather. Will likely purchase more shirts from this company!

Pacific Crest Rugby Shirt
Jeff T. (Mt. Pleasant, US)
Awesome shirt

I have a bunch of the Withernot rugbies and they never disappoint. I was a medium in the older shirts, now I’m a small.

Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Tanya (Pittsfield, US)
Best Rugby Ever! Look no more!

So I ordered a Rugby shirt in a S. I’m a small/medium in ladies. A small in men. I LOVE my new Rugby! So thick! Heavy like the vintage ones! I’m so happy with it! I Will definitely get more but the ones I like are out of stock. Rock On! Enjoy! Love the newsletter too!

Fitz Roy Rugby Shirt
Richard L. (Sandpoint, US)
Rugby shirt for winter

I purchased two shirts and like them very much. I find them ideal for winter nights in north Idaho.

Whistler Rugby Shirt
Dianne P. (Charleston, US)

Whistler Rugby Shirt

Stowe Rugby Shirt
Rajeev R. (San Francisco, US)
The best rugby shirt

No other comes close

Zermatt Rugby Shirt
Julia (New York, US)
Super Comfy

This rugby is made from breathable cotton and has an oversized fit. A great layer or perfect on its own, it's a timeless piece to any wardrobe.

Stowe Rugby Shirt
Jim R. (Arlington, US)
Where's the "football"? I'm ready to play!

Superior product. A "throwback: to the past. Great color combo. Slightly over cut, just the way I like.

Aspen Rugby Shirt
Richard M. (Colorado Springs, US)
“ Old School “ is still the best school

As rock climbers in the 70’s, authentic rugby shirts and painter pants were proven performers in terms of comfort and durability . This shirt is constructed of heavy weight fabric and appears to be “ bombproof “ . I expect it will be a pleasure to put a lot of mileage with this shirt !

Banff Rugby Shirt
JAMES M. (Palm Desert, US)
One size larger in fit.

Purchased two other rugby shirts in the past in medium which fit perfectly. Ordered the Banff shirt in medium but the fit was that of a large. Shirt is spectacular but order one size smaller than usual if you have ordered in the past since the Banff garment runs one size larger in fit.

Dockside Rugby Shirt
Kapyrick (Minneapolis, US)
Nice shirt!

Great color combination. Nice fit as well!

Ulysses Rugby Shirt
Adrian K. (Oakland, US)
Sturdy material, great design

I've been eyeing these shirts for a long time but was hesitant to believe they lived up to the hype. I finally pulled the trigger and and am glad I did. It's so difficult to find sturdy, high quality clothing and Withernot delivers on this. The rugby shirt feels halfway between a shirt and sweatshirt, which is exactly the weight I was looking for. I plan on buying more once my size is back in stock.

Aspen Rugby Shirt
EdmondsJim (Edmonds, US)
High quality rugby shirt

Soft, thick, colorful fabric with perfect collar that fits true to size -- just as described

Whistler Rugby Shirt
C. (Philadelphia, US)
Stop looking!

You can search all over the internet, but you will not find a better quality rugby shirt anywhere else. (I know- I’ve been searching for four years!). Heavyweight material, ultra fine attention to detail, slightly longer tails stay tucked in, true to size (I am 5’11”, 175 lbs) and Large is perfect. This Whistler is my third purchase, and I’ll buy another color as soon as it’s in stock.

Whistler Rugby Shirt
Sam L. (Sanford, US)

Comfortable, rich colors, heavyweight, feels good quality. I'm a woman and the shirt is very long on me, but it doesn't bother me too much and I knew that before ordering. Would love more transparency regarding production - the factories where the products are made, how materials are sourced, etc. Overall I waited for colors I really liked for months and am happy with my choice.